Relearning Self-Trust After Trauma
Relearning Self-Trust After Trauma
Trauma doesn’t just live in memories — it lives in the body, the nervous system, and the patterns we move through every day. One of the most common and least talked about effects of trauma is how it changes the way we make decisions. Whether it’s trouble trusting yourself, feeling frozen when faced with choices, or second-guessing everything after the fact, these struggles aren’t signs of weakness or indecisiveness. They’re signs of a nervous system that has learned to prioritize safety above all else.
Why Trauma Disrupts Decision-Making
When you experience trauma — especially chronic or relational trauma — your brain learns that the world can be unpredictable or unsafe. The nervous system adapts by becoming hypervigilant, constantly scanning for danger or signs of rejection. This state of alertness makes it incredibly hard to relax into intuition or trust your own perspective.
From a neuroscience standpoint, trauma impacts areas of the brain responsible for judgment, emotional regulation, and risk assessment. The amygdala (the brain’s alarm system) becomes overactive, while the prefrontal cortex (the part that helps you think clearly and weigh options) can go offline under stress. This imbalance can make even small decisions feel like high-stakes situations.
You might recognize some of these patterns:
-
Overanalyzing every choice, searching for the “perfect” one that guarantees safety
-
Avoiding decisions altogether for fear of making a mistake
-
Relying too heavily on others for guidance
-
Feeling intense regret or shame after making a choice
These reactions are protective — they once helped you survive uncertainty or danger. But in the present, they can keep you stuck in cycles of self-doubt and disconnection from your own inner compass.
The Cost of Not Trusting Yourself
When trauma teaches you that your instincts can’t be trusted, it can feel like being cut off from your internal GPS. You might look to others for direction or try to make decisions based on what seems “logical” or what others expect. Over time, this erodes self-confidence and reinforces the belief that you can’t handle life on your own terms.
This self-distrust often shows up in relationships, work, and even self-care. You may question your boundaries (“Am I being too sensitive?”), your desires (“Do I really want this, or am I just reacting?”), or your perceptions (“Maybe it wasn’t that bad.”). The good news is that trust can be rebuilt — slowly, gently, and consistently.
Rebuilding Trust in Yourself
-
Start Small.
You don’t have to begin with life-changing decisions. Practice tuning in to your preferences in low-stakes situations: What do I feel like eating? Which direction do I want to walk today? Each time you honor those small choices, you’re teaching your brain that it’s safe to listen to yourself. -
Notice Your Body’s Cues.
Trauma disconnects you from your body, but your body still holds valuable information. When you’re facing a decision, notice sensations — tightness, ease, warmth, or constriction. These signals often reveal whether something feels aligned or not. -
Pause Before Seeking External Input.
It’s natural to ask for advice, but before doing so, try checking in with yourself first. Ask, “What do I think?” or “What feels true for me?” This helps strengthen your inner voice. -
Offer Yourself Compassion.
You will make mistakes — everyone does. Healing means learning that a “wrong” decision doesn’t mean danger or failure. It’s simply information you can use next time. -
Work on Nervous System Regulation.
Practices like grounding, deep breathing, movement, or therapy can help calm the overactive threat response that drives decision paralysis. A regulated nervous system supports clearer thinking and greater self-trust.
The Path Forward
Relearning to trust yourself after trauma is not about becoming perfectly confident — it’s about reclaiming your right to have your own perspective, desires, and choices. Each time you listen to your inner voice, even in small ways, you reinforce the message that you are safe now, and that your own wisdom can guide you.
Healing doesn’t mean never feeling uncertain. It means knowing that even in uncertainty, you have the capacity to choose, to learn, and to keep moving forward.
This post was written by New Hope Counseling.
If you’re interested in setting up an appointment with one of our Licensed Therapists, contact us at 502-712-9604.
